HOW ROCKETS ARE MADE (Rocket Factory Tour – United Launch Alliance) – Smarter Every Day 231
Articles Blog

HOW ROCKETS ARE MADE (Rocket Factory Tour – United Launch Alliance) – Smarter Every Day 231

March 3, 2020


Five… Four…. Three… Two… One… Hey it’s me Destin, welcome back to Smarter Every Day I love rockets If you’ve been around this channel, you know that about me and today is like the best day ever because we’re going to learn how to build rockets. Just down the road from Huntsville, Alabama there’s a city named Decatur. And in that city, there is a rocket factory owned by a company called United Launch Alliance, and that factory has been cranking out incredibly reliable rockets for years. Because these orbital rockets have some of the same technologies in them as ballistic missiles, the knowledge about how to build them is protected. In the United States we have a set of regulations called ITAR International Traffic in Arms Regulations Because of ITAR, nobody’s going to let you walk into a rocket plant with a camera and film things. They can’t risk that stuff getting out and breaking the law. So there has to be an incredible amount of trust between the parties that want to film things, and the people that own the plant. Thankfully, I was given the opportunity to build that trust with ULA, when I went and watched the launch of the Parker Solar Probe, and I met the CEO of ULA on the launchpad. If you haven’t heard of this guy, Tory Bruno, then you’re in for a treat. He’s a legitimate rocket scientist who know his stuff inside and out. It was at this launch that Tory and I built trust with each other. Like, this guy is the real deal. The tour we’re about to go on has never been done on the internet, Tory literally takes us right up to the line of what he can show us, and all along the way he’s answering my technical questions, and he’s letting me explore the factory. So here we go, let’s take the first ever online tour of the United Launch Alliance rocket factory in Decatur, Alabama, with the CEO of ULA. Tory Bruno. Okay, we’ve got Tory, mic’d up now,
-Hi! and you’re gonna show me the rockets that are
– Yes, yeah fabricated at this facility? What do we have? Okay, so we’ve got an Atlas V on the side, this is kind of our workhorse, and it’s in the five meter payload fairing configuration. So that’s what we’re talking about here, it also has its SRB’s on the side, which is sort of its maximum lift version. When it’s got all five of those, we call it the beast. – And this is the Delta IV Heavy, and this is what you–thank you again, for letting me
-Yeah, of course participate, or at least see the Parker Solar Probe Yeah, that was fun huh -And that’s fabricated here in Decatur? Yes, yeah so three core rocket, you know literally literally three rockets kind of bolted together, and it is our largest rocket; it’s physically the largest rocket in the world right now, and it is what we used for Parker Solar Probe. -And this is what I want to talk about,
-Yeaaaaah this is Vulcan, and this rocket has never flown. Never flown, not yet. And you’re going to see, the first flight vehicle hardware in the factory being fabricated when we go in there today. -Today
-Yeah Okay!
-So this is our brand new rocket, you can think of it as kind of a derivative of those two in a way, so it’ll be large 5.4 meter diameter, so a little bit bigger than Delta, it can take six SRB’s, it’s a huge cavernous payload volume for the spacecraft, and this rocket has 30% more lift capability than this big three-core monster. -So when you say six SRB’s… Six of them, yeah.
-And that’s just to get out of the Earth’s gravity well Yes, right, exactly. -Can we go see the stuff? Yeah, let’s go see it. Okay, we’re at a rocket factory, let’s do it. -We’re gonna peel off to the right here
Okay Okay I’m seeing the grid here Yeah, so this is a barrel section from the booster over your head, actually from an Atlas. And I’m going to walk you down to the end of the factory where this first gets made; it’s the first thing we do Raw stock comes in the back door, gets machined, puts this curve in it, and then we’ll walk you all the way through to a completed version. -That’s awesome Okay, so there’s something unique about the north Alabama area here, correct me if I’m wrong, but there’s a little triangle: there’s a nuclear power station, there’s a steel mill, -Yes and there’s also a rocket factory like in a triangle. -That’s true
And then you got a river running between them -Yup and so you can bring in steel, you can make a rocket using the power from the nuclear plant,
-Yes is that why you’re here? That’s part of why we’re here, but it’s also because of the talent that we have here with University of Alabama and the other Alabama universities and the technician programs they have here; you just get an awesome workforce. And with the river, which is only a mile from here down Red Hat Road, we have the dock for our rocket ship, so we can transport our rockets out to the launchpad. This is the rocketship Tory’s talking about; ya see? Says so right on the side: “Rocketship. Rocketship navigates its way through several rivers up to the Mississippi River, down to the Gulf of Mexico, and then it heads to whatever pad the rockets will launch from. You should come back sometime and do the ship. Yeah, I should ride on the ship. Is that a thing?
-Yeah Can you do that?
-Yes that is a thing Okay we’re getting on a golf cart, and we have to cut cameras because we’re going to pass uh, not “secret stuff”, but things we can’t film. Right?
-Right Okay, cutting the camera off Ok we’re on the golf cart, and I’ve obtained permission to film straight up so you can’t see “that” which is pretty neat. Ok so, I can’t talk about that right now, can I No, we can’t show it to you, but I can tell you what it is That’s a Delta payload fairing so one of the smaller versions of the Delta’s payload fairing and then you’re passing by a heat shield here that would protect the RS-68 engine, from its own plume during flight. Ok… this is almost emotional. I mean, you know what it’s like to sit in class and study this stuff,
-Oh yeah, sure and then… cause you went to Cal Poly right? Right. Yeah, so this is me looking at all the stuff I’ve learned about and finally getting to see it. It’s on thing to see it on the pad, but uh it’s almost like a holy experience. Yeah well, you’re inside where it’s actually happening, where it all gets put together. Okay I’m starting to get the smell of the machine shop, the manufacturing, the cooling oil,
-Yep smell.
-You got it It’s my understanding you’re about to show me how to build a rocket from scratch. Yes I am. Okay, excellent, so we’re going to the door, right? Yes we are Okay this is what I wanted to see, here at ULA: This is the door. I can’t even get–it’s a wide angle lens–so that’s the door where the material comes in, right?
-Right That’s where the raw aluminum plate and other materials come in, and then this is the receiving area, and as they move that way turn into a rocket. So we’re about to build a rocket by going that way in the plant. Exactly. -Okay, I’m game let’s do this. Alright let’s do it. And this is an active manufacturing facility, so you’re just going to have to deal with the audio, there’s a lot of tools running. Yeah, sorry about that, but, ya know, building rockets. It’s good Oh wow, that is… that is really–can I go touch that? Yeah yeah, absolutely. This is a very, very expensive, piece–is that aluminum or stainless? -That’s aluminum
Aluminum Yeah -And is that fabricated here locally? -That’s imported?
No, yeah we buy that from a supplier and then it’s shipped here, comes in through the big door, if you will–and then we machine it down, we’re going to remove, more than two thirds of the material while retaining about ninety percent of the strength -in certain dimensions, right? And I will show you that, yeah -Okay, got it So this is our raw material, and uh, we’re going to go make a rocket. Okay. And so, all this is aluminum? That is a–
-All this is aluminum That’s a unique dimension, you normally don’t see plates of aluminum that wide and that long. No, so this is actually made especially for us in these dimensions, so that we can turn them into the barrel; the propellant tanks of the rocket itself. -Okay, so, so you’re tooling up an entire foundry of some type or a mill, a rolling mill.
-A rolling mill. Okay, gotcha So I’m going to show you a couple of different things before we get to the machine, so starting here with the raw stock of 7000-series aluminum it’ll eventually become a round rocket barrel, this is just after machining, and I wanted to point this out to you, because, this is our old style of grid that we machine in called an isogrid, and you’re familiar with what an isogrid is– -Isogrid, yes Right? So we have isentropic properties when we do the stress analysis, and you can see the triangular patterns in there. That’s not actually the ideal pattern for a rocket barrel, but it is what the analytical tools–the finite element analysis tools available to us when we designed the Atlas and Delta in the nineties, were available to us, and that’s why we have that pattern. Vulcan will be better, because the tools are better and you’ll see the difference when we walk down the line. -I have never thought about that So literally because in the nineties the FEA analysis could solve a triangle easily,
-Yes that’s why the isogrid is a triangle. -Exactly
I would’ve never thought that so, so basically if I understand correctly, you–can I touch this? Yeah, touch if you want. I’m going to ask you that every time
-Yeah, that’s alright So basically because you can compute the force coming in one member,
-Yep to a node and the forces coming out the other member that’s how you arrived at isogrid. Exactly. -Okay, fantastic Yeah it’s sort of an interesting thing, in the real world, how the engineering tools that are available, dictate the kind of designs that we use. Got it. What’s your safety factor on flying here? Oh, so it depends on what part of the rocket we’re talking about, anything that would be pressurized when people are around, it has a higher safety factor than what is not, but the factors we work with in flight are anywhere from 1.1, to never really higher than 1.25. Got it, yes. I mean it’s very different than like, designing a railroad car where your factor of safety might be 7 or 8. Oh no, yeah. And a factor of safety is, if you can compute the stress that the thing will break at, you design it to 1.1 times that Right, 10% more load carrying capability, and really a factor of safety is really a factor of ignorance. You have a factor of safety because you’re not truly sure what might happen to it in the field, so you give yourself just a little bit more. And you talked about rail, big tractors are another one; we have big factors of safety like 7 times, 12 times, when we do rockets, we like to keep it closer to like just 10%, maybe 20%, cause we can’t afford the weight. Got it, because every every 1000th of an inch that you put in this webbing here, over the course of a huge part like this, you’re talking tons on the whole rocket. Yes -Okay Exactly, and this is a booster plate, and so every seven pounds of that costs me a pound of spacecraft. -So how long does it take to machine that? You have the tools here to machine this isogrid. Yeah this is about a two day operation altogether. Is this curled like a potato chip in this direction, or in this direction? In the long direction. -In the long direction And you’re going to see that operation as we walk to the other end.
-Nice That’s what the twenty-five-ton brake presses are for. Yeah, cause if you’re curling along the long direction, you require a tremendous amount of force, and you have to have alignment to keep it straight during the bend. Exactly
-Okay Is that a pressure vessel? I mean would that hold pressure or would there be a liner on the inside? It is a pressure vessel, but actually on the booster because it’s liquid propellant, most of the pressure is at the bottom just coming from hydraulic head. We only have a few PSI of gas on top to keep the propellant down against the outlet feeding it into the engine. Got it. This is not something I expected to see. These guys are–they appear to be putting–are they washing? What are they doing? They are. So the first thing that happens to those big plates, is we plane them–we make them flat–and so these guys are going over an operation that’s just been done, they’re cleaning it up, they’re looking for any imperfections, and what you’re going to see in the factory that I think is really cool; you know we’re building rockets we’re at the pinnacle of technology, and you’re going to see high tech robotic operations, but mixed in you’re going to also see craftsmanship, with people who are very skilled, and have great attention to detail like these guys. They’re going to go over every inch of that thing and make sure that the automated machine that planed it, didn’t leave any features we don’t want. So if like a piece of the tool broke or something like that
-Exactly Shattered, whatever. Yeah so, are these your fly-cutters here? Yeah, basically end mills, some of them are side mills, but yes. Gotcha, am I allowed to look at this fly cutter? Yeah yeah, go ahead, sure. -Wow Isn’t that cool? I love machining It’s a secret passion of mine Yeah me too So you went to Alabama, right? -I did So do you guys do a lotta sorta machine shop time in your engineering degree? -Not a whole lot, but we do take a class or two, for my undergrad I did that. But my dad had an old lathe and mill in the garage when I was growing up. -Cool
Yeah that’s cool stuff The other thing I’ll share with you, you can see all that flow down there, we actually recover all these chips so even though we’re going to take the majority of the material away by machining it off–subtractive manufacturing–we capture all of it, we send it right back to the supplier and it comes back to us in a plate a month later. -That’s awesome That, is that coolant? That’s coolant but it’s mostly water. Mostly water, so it’s capturing the chips. That’s a tremendous amount of water flow! Yeah, well, chips are heavy. [Both chuckle] It’s hard to get a scale for that. It’s hard to get a scale for that, but that is a lot of fluid. Oh, there’s a whole river of coolant there. -Oh yeah, you can see it Are you looking for places where the tooling broke? No we’re looking for chips or, debris that might be on it, we only have about a 5000th of a thickness, -Right So, a small chip would be outside of the tolerance zones. -Right Thank you very much, my name’s Destin. -Jeff
Nice to meet you Jeff. Nice to meet you That’s cool, the human story is what’s really cool to me, that’s amazing. -Me too Here’s one that, uh, I think this guy’s actually running. So you can see way down there where the cutting head is, These are actually the plates for Vulcan flight two, -Really
the second Vulcan that’ll go. So you know what we outta do is we outta, like, steal you a chip down there, so you’ll have a chip from the Vulcan rocket when it goes to space. -Can I, can I stick on in my pocket? Yeah. -Ok, I’m gonna–
It’s a little sharp, be careful. -I’ll be careful, I’ll take a little one Nothing to see here It’s okay, you be careful. A chip from Vulcan, here’s your chip. Guard it with your life. -Alright we’re in trouble but don’t tell anybody We’re in trouble but don’t tell anybody, Tory Bruno said it was okay if I stuck a chip in my pocket. So, these machine are CNC, correct? Yes. Okay and, are these specially made machines, or because usually you, you don’t plane a surface that
-They were, yeah wide.
-No, generally when you’re in this kind of factory you’re going to see tooling that comes from big tooling manufacturers, but it has been designed especially for this application. so all of this is custom stuff. -Really -So for example, the head here it probably normal, but the ways on the machine, this is incredibly long for a mill. Yes, exactly, very very long, and very large. -Gotcha
Very, ya know, big width. That lets us do more than one plate at a time. -So if one of these machines go down, what does that do to you? That would be a big impact, but fortunately we have more than one, so we would always still have the other machines running. And so what would happen is we’d get it fixed and then we would catch up on an off-shift. -Because I’ve kept up with your launch record, and you always meet schedule, is it because you have redundancy built in to this part of the process? That is part of it. So yes, this factory was actually built with the idea in mind of building as many as forty rockets a year, and so we have so much capacity, it’s easy for us to kind of make up for little challenges like that along the way, cause nowadays you fly maybe twelve or fifteen times a year tops. -Right, okay. So you’re not at capacity. No, not even close. -But you want to be, this is a commercial for that. Yes we do, yeah we do. Okay so that moment right there where Tory Bruno is joking about the capacity of his rocket plant; it reminds me of a very specific moment in an audio book I love called Seveneves. Now the beautiful thing about Smarter Every Day being sponsored by Audible, is I can use moments like that to go to Nashville and introduce you to someone I’ve been wanting to meet for a really long time. Okay so we’re going to drive a couple hours away, and we’re going to meet a lady named Mary Robinette Kowal. She was the narrator for Seveneves by Neil Stephenson, and she did an amazing job, listen to the first line of the book: “The moon blew up without warning, and for no apparent reason.” Let’s go talk to Mary Robinette about this book. What a cool place to meet someone for the first time. I’m Destin, you doing alright? Yeah I’m doing great, nice to meet you!
-Good to meet you, you doing ok? Okay, this is Mary Robinette Kowal
-Hi! who is an amazing narrator of audio books. -Thanks
You are! I’ve spent, like, well over twelve hours with you, mostly in a tractor but that’s another story, but, the book that I want to tell people about is called “Seveneves” by Neil Stephenson. And this looks like it was a challenging book to narrate. It was more than a little bit challenging, it’s, uh, technically completely accurate, it’s got this huge international cast, so basically something hits the moon–they never figure out what it is shatters it, and that causes them to have to get off the planet real darn fast, because pieces of the moon are going to start raining down, and causing destruction for five thousand years. Mass destruction
-Mass destruction! This is why I wanted to do it on this video, because Tory Bruno is talking about building more rockets, but you’ve also written a book yourself, Calcu– You’ve written many books, but there’s one in particular that’s similar to Seveneves, “The Calculating Stars”, yeah I slam an asteroid into Washington, D.C. in 1952 which kicks off the space program, fast! Also building a lot of rockets, a lot fast.
-A lot of rockets There you go, so go get one of these two books, she’s kind of downplaying that a little bit you’ve won the Hugo Award, the Locus Award, and the Nebula. That is correct. For that book, that’s a big deal to win all three.
-It’s three Go get her books, [URL] Which one would you recommend? Seveneves. Seveneves? I’m going to recommend your book even though I haven’t read it, I’m guessing its’ going to be amazing It’s called? “The Calculating Stars”
-The Calculating Stars Okay, that’s it, let’s go back and build more rockets with Tory Bruno. Here we go: Yeah so if anybody needs their own personal rocket, Tory’s your guy. Oh yeah, just let me know. So you remember we were looking at isogrids down there and we were looking at those Delta panels, so if you look at this panel that’s being machined, you can see that they’re rectangles. So this is an orthogrid, which is not symmetric, but we’re able to do that now, because the engineering analysis tools are better. And so Vulcan switches to orthogrid, takes about half the amount of time to manufacture, and these panels will actually be stronger. so as I look along the orothogrid here, so you’re gonna break it along the long side so this is gonna be a really long skinny potato chip looking thing.
-Exactly So what happens when you’re breaking along that line? Because you have a section in the middle of the webbing That’s gonna have the most stress Yes But along the longitudinal webbing you’re gonna have, it’s gonna be difficult there. So actually the way the break process works is we’ll bring it in flat, and as we break it, we’re moving just a small amount of material each time and we roll the part in and out, so the amount of strain and work hardening that we get is actually very uniform across that width -Okay. Got it. But the issue that you brought up is one of the reasons why that’s done by people. It’s a hand operation. So there’s no CNC on the curving of the brake press, it’s all craftsmanship.
-Really? That’s amazing. So, so these are Vulcan? Yes, these are Vulcan panels these panels are going to space. -Wow, it’s got a lubricant on it, it feels like. From the machining; from the machining process.
-Got it. -And so, the orthogrid, just looking at it, the webbing looks thinner, so it looks like it’s much more light-weight. It is, yes. Are you allowed to tell me a percentage? I can’t give you the number yet,
-Okay ask me next year.
-Okay, I’ll do that But it is absolutely lighter weight and stronger than the old isogrid design. And it takes half as long to make. -Why does it take less time to make? You can see how much simpler that pattern is, So the CNC machine has more straight runs in a simpler pattern, and it just… it’s that much faster to machine. So those are fancy space saw horses? Yes they are, yeah. [Both chuckle] So these are the panels that have been machined, they’ve been cleaned up a little bit. And they’re getting ready to go into these 25-ton brake presses, bump presses in order to potato chip them, up into a curve. -Okay, those presses right there? Those presses right there. -Okay, so I’m noticing that there’s no hydraulic pressure in the center of the press, There’s just a really… it’s a strong back.
-Right It’s a strong back. -What is the technical term for it? Strong back.
-Is it really? Yeah!
-Okay, awesome So, so, can I look at this and then look at that? Absolutely.
-Okay am I allowed to walk over there? Yeah. So you can see that these guys actually have a little bit of curvature along their length; we’re going to actually take that out. That helps up form the curvature along this axis, more evenly. So it’s sort of an intermediate manufacturing step, if you will. -Is it done on purpose, or is it a function of stress relief? It is done on purpose.
-Oh okay, gotcha. Of course this is, again, isogrid.
-Isogrid, got it. So this is Atlas V? Right.
-Okay So at some point you have internal stresses in the material.
-Yes Do you have an oven here to anneal? No, we let them do what’s called “artificial aging of aluminum,” so 7000 series will do that, so we’re going to put a certain amount of work hardening in here, and we like that–we actually like the properties that gives us and then what the–sort of–room temperature artificial aging does, is even that out for us. So we’re entering the space of–I notice you’re saying hello to everyone; people know you, don’t they? Yeah, oh yeah.
-That’s cool So, we’re entering the area where we’ve got this tooling here, that’s holding this stuff. These are the guys–oh they’re actually doing something now. Yeah, so that’s a, you know that’s a skirt and they’ve just manufactured it, just put the curve into it, we can walk over there; we’ll let them finish what they’re doing we can talk to them if you like.
-Okay. Yeah that’d be great This is a finished part here? That’s Vulcan.
-Yes. Vulcan flight hardware right here, It takes five of these to make a complete barrel, for a methane tank, and then another five on top of that will be the liquid Oxygen tank. And we’re going to show you friction stir welding which is how these are joined. -Gotcha. Alright, so here is our two 25-ton bump presses. So this big beam in the center is very very stiff, that’s why it’s so tall, because the hydraulics are on the edges. And what the technicians are going to do–our craftsmen–are going to take one of these big, flat panels on these roller carts, and they literally have patterns that are pre-formed, that we’ve made, and they’re going to roll them in and out, and have that knife edge come down and hit it, and slowly, potato chip it up, while they’re matching it to the physical pattern, until they have it just right, and so we saw all this high-tech computer computer controlled machining down there, now this is pure craftsmanship where they’re going to do it by eye and by pattern, and achieve very tight tolerances in doing so. -Do you have any plans to computer control this in the future? No, this is a process that you will always get better results doing it by hand. That’s amazing! So, oh I didn’t even think about having to hold the material as it comes out. -Exactly, yeah. Let’s walk down and you’ll see one, they’re working on that one right there. -Okay That’s a skirt, which is why it’s short. Hey guys! So, so one question I have Tory is, as they lift the part, obviously it’s being supported by the top, it’s going to deflect.
-Yes So how do they know if they–oh it’s pressing now.
-Yeah, so you can watch. -And you’ll see. See now, they’re lifting it a little bit. Bumping it again. So now they’re making another adjustment, and they’re going to bump it again. This is all done by eye and by hand. You could do this with a, sort of a remote controlled operation, but you could not get the same lightweight tanks out of that, you’d have to work with much thicker pieces of metal, and you wouldn’t have as high a performing rocket. So I notice, she’s looking with her eyes, she’s operating–is she operating the press with her foot? -Yes She’s operating the overhead crane,
-Yes and also that–
-She has what’s called a “walk along” or a “creeper,” just like you would have, say, on your truck, to tighten a fence or to get yourself out of a ditch, she’s doing all three things at once, while watching the curvature she’s creating in this part. She is fully engaged. Oh yes. That’s amazing. Don’t look at us, don’t let us distract you– should we go away? We’re distracting them.
-Yes yeah Let’s go let’s go let’s go Yeah we don’t want to have the uh, “Destin and Tory Discrepancy Report” on that. [Both Laugh] And here’s finished product. And this is all for Atlas, as you can tell by seeing the isogrid, and then we’re going to walk down the aisle and we’re going to show you how these get joined together into a tube. –the welding? Oh! I almost forgot Yeah we want to go to chem processing, right? -Oh yeah, is this where stuff is anodized?
Yeah Let’s go it, yeah yeah yeah. Okay, so now we’re in one of the world’s largest plating facilities, or chemical processing facilities, where we’re going to etch the panels down, so that we have a very consistent high quality known surface, and then we’ll anodize them, which is plating to create a very thick oxide layer, to give the aluminum corrosion resistance and a little bit of hardness. -Oh that is a very specific tool there. Yes it is. -To hold that part. Yup You know all this, Destin, but this is sort of, classic, bare aluminum and it automatically forms its own Oxide layer right away, which is why it’s sort of white in color, but we don’t get very good corrosion resistance naturally, especially from a 7000-series aluminum, because it’s not very thick. And it tends to be porous, and so that’s why we anodize it. -That’s bad for fatigue, right? Yes, yes, very bad. So we can get a phenomenon called stress corrosion cracking for example If we allow corrosion to be present in these kinds of materials. So is this the chemical milling process before you anodize? No that will all happen inside the booths we’re gonna take you to. This is really for cleaning because we’re gonna – you know there’s a lot of machining activity, there’s a lot of chemicals that are going to be involved. And so we like to have a known condition when it goes in and out of the tanks. And this particular dome is in here to be inspected. Look at that! Yeah. So what am I looking at? So you’re looking at us rinsing and washing a ring, before it comes further down to this booth which is actually an inspection booth. Gotcha! So this is pre-anodization. Yes So just to connect the parts, we made the part down there. Pulled it up on this crane, pulled it over here, Brought it over there and inspected it one more time We’re going to take it down there and clean it. We’re going to inspect it, and then we’re going to go around where you can’t see right now and anodize it. and we’re going to drop it off the other side? and then when it’s all done, it’ll come down the other side. Gotcha. So this is like the rainbow arc of anodization! Yes it is! Yeah. Ok, cool. So Shannon, what’s your role here? So, I work on the commercial crew hardware,
-Okay I’m in the production engineering group, so I work with the design team and the technicians, to interpret the drawings, and make sure they’re building it correctly. Give them all the procedures and processes they need. -What kind of engineer are you? So I’m in the production engineering group, so manufacturing engineering. How’s it going? That’s the thing about working at ULA, you never know when the CEO is going to walk in on you while you’re cleaning the floor. [Both laugh] So you said Sulfuric Acid to do the etching? Yes, and that’s part of the plating, so anodization always uses, typically one of three acids, you use Sulfuric, you use Chromic acid, or other organic acids, so that’s part of it, because that releases the Oxygen in the bath, some of it bubbles off, but the rest of it ends up attaching to the material, creating that corrosion resistant layer. -So this is a vat that you would dip the part into? Yes, in fact here we are. Here’s our Sulfuric Acid anodization, so there’s a part in there right now that’s going to sit there for a prescribed amount of time, it’s heated, and then we’re passing current through it because ultimately this is actually a plating process. See, here’s our DI (deionized) tap water rise, that we were talking about. Yeah. So you literally put the part in there and you give it a shower. Give it a shower! -That’s awesome! Holy cow, that’s intimidating. -Yeah -That’s intimidating…
Keep your hands out of there. [Both laugh] We’ll plate, we’ll rinse, we’ll plate again, we’ll clean, then it goes out where you were before, for inspection. Here’s what they look like when they come out, so you can see that sort of characteristic green/bronze color of an anodized aluminum surface. And as they naturally age it’ll become more and more bronze, so when you see an Atlas rocket on the pad, and you look at the booster, it has that very distinctive bronze color, this is why, because of what we just looked at here. Maybe we’ll just let you peek over the edge, would you like to? -Yeah that’d be great. So at this point we’ve finished plating, cleaning, and inspecting, and here are the panels, lowered down from where we took that last shot. -And now what? Now they’re going to get friction stir welded together into barrels, forming the body of the rocket, and the propellant tanks. -So one question I have about this next step, is when you weld something, usually you tack it together all around the perimeter before you do the final welding, because the heat will draw it up -Right
So how do you account for that here? So we fixture it, we hold it in place mechanically, because the interesting thing and the reason you want to do a friction stir welding is because you don’t melt any material. In conventional welding, you bring the parts together, and then as you say, you tack them to hold them, and then you fill in that gap with filler material that you’ve melted. It fuses to the parent material melting it a little bit too, and then you get a heat-affected zone, and that entire weld joint has different mechanical properties than the original material. But when you friction stir weld, you never melt anything. You bring the parts tightly together, and you bring a head that spins, and literally stirs the material together as it moves. That gives you a stronger joint, which means you can thin down the entire part, and get a much lighter weight higher performance structure. -So what is the head made out of, that can withstand the higher temperatures? So the heads are always made out of tool steel, high strength materials that can stand that over and over and over we’re welding aluminum so we just need that difference. -So the melting point of aluminum is so much lower than the head -Yes
of the tool part… and it never quite melts. It gets warm, it gets a little soft, because of the heat generated through the friction, but we never actually erase all of its mechanical properties, like you do with a classic, conventional fusion weld, you literally melt the material. And I’m not allowed to film this, and I’m not allowed to film that… -Nope What if I peek over there, can I peek…?
-You can peek Peek over there, but it was blocked out so people couldn’t see that. So now, those big plates that you saw machined and you saw bent, and you saw anodized, have to get friction stir welded together into a barrel to form an Atlas booster, or in the case of what you see over there right now is the Vulcan first flight liquid oxygen tank. -That’s it, okay so that is the first vertical assembly of Vulcan. -Right, and so that tank will go to space, and it will lift the Astrobotic Peregrine Lander back to the moon, which is our first mission on Vulcan. -Really?
-Yeah. I didn’t know you had a lunar mission.
-Yeah yeah, that’s our first mission. That’s awesome, okay!
-Yeah it’s super cool we’re really excited about that. -Yeah So what you’re seeing here, is uh, five–these are actually Atlas, but for the version that’s Vulcan, five of those big panels that start out flat and thick, machined down, they’re fixtured up in there, and if you look right there you can see that sort of bright aluminum stripe that runs up it, that is a completed friction stir weld. -And you have a rotary stage at the bottom that’s turning it, and so you have the weld on one side.
-Right, cause we’re going to do one, two, three–it takes five of those panels to make a Vulcan, so we’ve gotta do five, we’ve got to do all of those welds. -Wow
So we’ll rotate it, then we’ll do another one, rotate it, do another one. And over there is a finished Atlas barrel, if you’d like to kinda see what it looks like.
-That would be great, yeah. So these are friction stir welds? Yeah, so this is an Atlas tank, and by the way you can–maybe it’s a little hard to see from down on the ground, but this is a lot smaller than that big beast over there. -Right. And so here’s our classic isogrid pattern– -What’s our diameter on Atlas? So Atlas is a little bit closer to 3.8 meters, and this is a 5.4 meter diameter rocket on Vulcan. -Got it
So even just a little bit bigger than Delta. -That’s a lot more volume payload. Oh yeah, yeah so r², you know the math. -Yeah, so like, it’s better to order one large pizza than two medium pizzas, -That’s right
and so when you have a large rocket, you get more than just two small rockets. -You got it.
That’s the easiest way to say that. Okay, so this is a friction stir weld? -So here’s a friction stir weld, so you can feel that. -Yeah, you can feel where it heated up and grew a little bit. -Yeah. We just bring these parts tightly together, we bring a head down that spins very very fast, it heats it, softens it, stirs it together without ever melting it, and we just run all the way down the length of the barrel, and that’s how we join them together, and we get a stronger part, and a lighter rocket. -But do you do that on both sides? I guess my question is, do you have a tool on the outside, and the inside? -Yes, you have to react against something, so there is such a thing as a self-reaction friction stir weld, and I’ll show you that too,
-Okay but for these parts yeah, you have to react it against so you don’t just push the material through. -Gotcha So now, we’re going to look at a different friction stir welding process called “circumferential”, cause we’re going to attach a dome or a barrel, self reacting friction stir welding, where we don’t have to have something holding the part up from behind. -It seems like that would be difficult though, because like when you have a hammer and you’re hitting something on an anvil, You know, it squishes and molds the metal together against the anvil.
-Yes, right But if you’re just pushing, how does it not just push out the other side? -Well it has to do with how we fixture it, and some very clever things in the friction stir weld head, which is why I’m not going to let you film it. I can’t film it?
-No. Okay… You cannot look at that part at the end of this big assembly up there, that’s the weld head. -Which part can I not look at?
Yeah this guy right up here, so the end of that.
-That part I can’t look at? Don’t look at that.
-Okay, got it. [Both laugh] -A little video magic This is why we’re taking your card. -This is why you’re taking my card, because of ITAR. It seems like you would be more prone to fracture on the back side. -You are, there are some…”tricks and techniques” to making this work well, especially a self-reacting process like this one, where you don’t have any support, to uh, you know protect that joint. -And what’s the advantage of doing that? You can, seal a tank? It’s like when you sew a pillow together, that last stitch is important, but you have to do it from outside the pillow. -One of the things we have to deal with is, when you come around, because of the way that head works, you actually leave a terminal hole. So where you terminate, there’s a hole that penetrates the tank, that we then have to later seal up as well. But it’s worth doing that, because this process is so fast. -This tooling here holds, everything…
So a big tank like the tube we just filmed would come all the way down here, where where we would either have a dome or a ring, that would then get the friction stir weld to put it all together. -On the circumference?
On the circumference. -Got it, so there’s two different operations: there’s a longitudinal friction stir weld, and there’s a circumferential one– -Exactly
Okay friction stir weld. In fact you can see a dome over there that’s being set up for its attachment.
-So that’s a smaller tank, so would that be oxygen? Yeah that’s Atlas, that’s just the dome. That’s just the dome attached to its ring, it’ll get attached to a big long barrel. -Gotcha, sounds good. Okay! Alright and–there’s an X-Ray booth to X-Ray joints, and then there’s also a uh, a pressure booth where small bottles get pressurized, and then outside this building there’s a booth where we put pressure and fluid in the big tanks to make sure everything seals, just like any kind of normal pressure vessel process. -So this is, humans know how to make pressure vessels, so you build it, you weld it, you seal it, and then you take it up to a certain pressure above what you think it’s going to see, and then that tests it and you come back down and then you fly it. You got it. [DESTIN VOICEOVER]
After the booster’s assembled, the plumbing is installed, the insulation is applied as necessary, and the rocket engines are mounted. We weren’t able to film details about the engines themselves, But they’re made offsite by a variety of different sources. [ON-SITE DESTIN]
It’s really interesting being able to peek inside and see the isogrid and understand where we started with the plate. -Yeah
That’s pretty fascinating. Alright so we built the booster, now we’re going to talk about the second stage of that rocket. -Okay
The part that goes to space. So the technology we had before that we walked through, was aluminum; rigid structures, very high performance. but on a booster, you could afford seven kilograms of inner mass before it costs you a kilogram of spacecraft–on the upper stage it’s literally one-to-one. So we switched to an even higher performance technology, so now we’re going to walk the Centaur line; our very high performance upper stage. We use stainless steel–
-To be clear, the Centaur is like, it’s like the tractor, it’s the heartbeat of American space kind of, right? -Yeah yeah, so it is in fact the highest performance upper stage ever flown, it is the last stage of the rocket that takes the spacecraft, all the way into space and into its destination orbit.
-Gotcha, okay. Alright so this is a gore(?), and these are kinda fun, these are gonna be resistance welded, you can’t friction stir weld them because the material is too thin, and shaped into a dome–and you can touch this if you want, Destin. That’s it. Oh my goodness. And that’s a pressure vessel?
-That’s a pressure vessel. And it’s going to be huge,
-Okay I had no idea, I– it’ll be over 3 meters in diameter, 40ft long. -So, I can just tell you this, like, I’ve done the math to say, if I have a certain thickness pressure vessel, it’ll be this much weight, but it’s a totally different thing to actually feel it. -Oh yeah
It’s like uh… It’s just nothin’, it’s nothin’…
-Nothing there, nothing there. That’s amazing, ok I can understand. -Half the thickness of a dime.
Wow, okay, -Yeah
That’s incredible! So, you put these together in a sphere? We’ll put those together in a dome, and then there will be a cylindrical section that’s almost 40 feet long, and then another dome on the bottom. So this stuff comes in in big coil rolls, almost like you would buy sheet steel, you know at Home Depot or something. And then we stretch it, and then we cut it into those shapes, and even as thin as that is, we’ll actually machine it still, kinda honing it, to get even just a little bit thinner than we can buy it. So these are sharp edges so be careful. They came off a big roll, and we’ve laid it out, we’ve cut it, we’re gonna stretch it,
-It’s all stainless steel? Stainless steel.
-So these are–are they called mandrels, or no not mandrels, what are these called? These are dyes. -Yeah so these are dyes, and they’re going to be used to stretch it and cut it for those gore(?) shapes that you saw for a dome.
-Okay That really gives you a sense of how little material and the margins you’re playing with here. -Yeah. And then we didn’t talk about it, but uh, the 5-meter composite payload fairing for Atlas used to be made in Switzerland by a company called Ruag, they’re going to make the Vulcan 5-meter payload fairing, and so I asked them–this is another one of those strategic business partnerships, to take their factory out of Switzerland, and it’s actually on the other side of that wall. -Really, so you brought the factory to America?
Brought the factory to America. And there was enough volume there that they were totally on board. -Yeah. One of the strategies for having a very succesful first flight on Vulcan, is to fly it before you fly it. -With parts from Atlas? You got it. So lots of the technologies on Vulcan could be flown on Atlas, and so we’ll slowly start bringing them into Atlas over the next year, we’ll fly Vulcan payload fairings on Atlas, We’ll fly a lot of the same technology you just saw, pretty much everything but the BE-4 engine, will have flown on Atlas at least once before we try it out on Vulcan. -Gotcha. I notice you have pictures of the commercial crew all over the walls here. Yes, yeah so we’re flying people, that’s a whole other game, you know, 135 in a row is, we’re very proud of that but… when it’s a person up there, when you can shake hands with the payload, you know, talk to them and meet their friends and relatives, it’s a whole other thing. And so they’ve been to the factory many times, to see their rocket, and it means a lot to my employees to know them, and to know that we’re flying people, and so we’re just that much more careful, and we have pictures of them everywhere to sort of remind us, you know that’s Sunny, and that’s Nicky.
-Sunny’s amazing isn’t she Yeah, yeah.
-She really is. Here is, sort of the, completed product. Stainless steel, you can see, just look at that.
-I didn’t ask, I’m allowed to touch, right? You can touch it, yeah.
-Okay. Okay, is that machined after it’s welded? -Before, yeah before.
Before, okay. So you make a groove maybe.
-Yeah Gotcha.
-And we actually plane the whole surface. So as thin as that was, what you saw over there, we actually plane it and thin it out just a little bit more; we want it a little thinner than you can buy it. -Really The cool thing about Centaur is, you know a booster… is typically 80% mass fraction. And… most upper stages get, 85-ish. Centaur is around 90, so literally the highest performance upper-stage ever. Okay, so we saw the dome, that’s the cylindrical tank that the dome will be fitted to. One on the top, one on the bottom, and the one on the bottom is where the engine will be. -Is this the same thickness metal we’re talking about? It is, yeah so that giant thing you’re looking at, 40ft long, half the thickness of a dime You see all the rings? That’s all tooling, so that we can support that shape, so it doesn’t just collapse on its own. And when we actually put the domes on it, we’ll have to grab it at either end and stretch it, or pressurize it depending on where it is in the factory. -Oh okay so, it’s the opposite of a bulk(?) buckling problem. You have hoop stress and you have ring stress. Ring stress is the issue here. -Exactly, exactly.
Okay Wait, am I saying that right? Axi–okay. So you have axial stress and you have ring stress,
ring stress is the problem here. -So you could think of it as a longitudinal buckling problem if you want, because the weight of the structure itself would overcome the stiffness, and it would–you’d start with a hoop and it would just kinda buckle like this on the top and fold in. -Gotcha, awesome. But we have the same friction stir welding idea there? No, so this material is so thin that you cannot friction stir weld it. So this is all done with resistance arc welding instead, and on Centaur III, which is what we fly on Atlas today, this is a labor-intensive operation. 180,000 welds, they’re all setup by hand, so it takes many many hours and quite a bit of time to build this sort of “Ferrari” of an upper-stage. -Yeah.
Vulcan will be robotic and automated. -Really, that’s amazing. Dome on the front, dome on the back, tank, the engine–well there’s not a dome on the back, that’s where the engine goes. -So there will actually be a dome, so that you have a sump to collect propellant in to draw it into the engine, so you don’t waste as much propellant, and what you can’t see on the inside is a bulkhead, to separate the liquid oxygen and the liquid hydrogen from one another. -Got it. So, where are the engines at, are they here? -Uhhhhh… let’s see. Have we got an RL10 open out of a crate that we could show him? -We’re gonna go upstairs.
Okay–oh! Yeah so, we’re gonna– so there’s a final assembly that gets done in a clean room.
-Okay And that’s the best place, so we’ll look down, you’ll see a whole bunch of them, they’ll be engines, that’ll be better. Okay, so this is the final assembly area for Centaur, this is a clean room, that’s why we’re up here, the people down there who are on break right now would be in bunny suits. So you’re looking at the business end, those red covers are on the bottom of the nozzle of the, RL10 rocket engine. And you can see that you have a standard configured one with a single engine, -Right there
Right there, but to its left you see a dual. -Okay, that’s strange. That Centaur will carry astronauts to space. -That one will?
That one will. -That’s amazing
Yeah -That’s a pretty big deal, so how do you–I mean that changes everything about how you operate the thing. Have you ever flown a dual-engine Centaur? We have, but it’s been decades. -Really?
And so this is reintroducing a, kind of a historic but one configuration we haven’t done recently. -So this right here, I’m seeing, that’s Mars 2020 right there? Yeah -So that’s the Centaur that’s going to take Mars 2020 to Mars? Yes it is, yes it is. -So you do the bulk of the heavy lift or the, I guess the “far push” you could say, with Centaur. We do, yeah so the booster’s job is to get you into space, typically depending on the payload but typically you’re not quite orbital at the end of first stage burn, and then Centaur will take you orbital, bring you to your parking orbit, and then once you’re lined up correctly with, you know the right sort of argument, of perigee, then it will send you off on the final burns to get you lined up for wherever you’re going, and in this case it’s interplanetary missions, so we’re going out to Mars. -So, the brains that drives the Centaur, where is that at? Are you integrating GNC at this point? We are. So on the back end of that is a flight controls computer, and you know inertial measurement sensor and other sensors, uh rate sensors that are the guidance system; they’re always attached to the upper stage obviously because if you attached them to the booster and it separated, you would’ve lost your brains. So they’re always up here. Okay, final assembly. -It is
and I’m not–so yeah this is, this is the big show, right? This is the big show, we call this the “great hall of rockets”, because as you can see, There’s rockets way down there and they just keep going all the way to that big roll-up door, they’re in final assembly, and when they get to that door, They roll outside, down to the Rocketship, and off to the launchpad. -So, this gentleman over here is doing final assembly on a rocket? He is absolutely doing that, yes he is. -That’s amazing, and so wow just having a person for scale is pretty impresive there. Yep.
-That’s amazing, so what are we looking at? These are Deltas on this side of the aisle, and Atlas on this side, and way down there we’ll walk you back down there, but Vulcan will start at the far end of the Delta line and slowly work its way down, eventually replacing Delta entirely. -So Delta and Atlas are being phased out, correct?
Yes, yes. So do you know the number of missions you have left for each one? I do! -Okay, are you allowed to talk about it? No.
-Okay. [Both Laugh] So the last question I asked Tory was very interesting, and before I show you that though, I want to say, you should be following this guy on Twitter. He has a legitimate, technical engineering answer for everything he’s asked. He’s very engaged in the space community, it is legitimately fun to watch Tory Bruno interact on Twitter. So there’s that. Now if you’re into space, you know that I didn’t ask two things in this video. I didn’t talk about engines very much, and I also didn’t ask about Tory Bruno’s competitors. I did that; that’s over on the second channel. He gave me really good answers, if you want to hear what Tory Bruno thinks about those two things, go to the second channel, link in the video description, also a link to Tory Bruno’s Twitter. Okay, let’s get back to the last question I asked Tory on this tour. I have noticed that there’s not a lot of stuff in this plant that’s going to low Earth orbit. -That’s correct
And, and uh, that’s intentional? Yes, our specialty are the higher-energy, more difficult orbits, things like Mars 2020, an interplanetary mission.
-Right, and that’s… Literally right there, yeah, but we don’t call it Mars 2020, here. -What do you call it?
We call it Mars 2020…20, -Why would you do that?
Because it’s our 20th trip to Mars. -Really? That’s amazing
Mhm -That’s impressive! So your job is to get it there,
Yes. And then what happens with the payload at that point? So it’ll re-enter, it’ll come down to the surface of Mars, as you mentioned it’s a rover. We really set it on its way, so Centaur is no going to go all the way with it to Mars, we’re going to put that energy in, as an escape velocity here at Earth, greater than “1c3”, as we say in the technical world, and then that will carry it all the rest of the way, it will establish its own orbit and land. -That’s impressive, that’s what I like about Tory, he knows his stuff. So thank you very much for this tour!
-Oh yeah, you’re welcome. This was absolutely incredible, I’ve lived near this plant my entire life; well I guess it hasn’t been here my entire life. But as long as it’s been here, I’ve lived near this plant and always wanted to come inside, so thank you very much for extending your flight and giving us this tour, this was amazing. I’m glad you came by. Thank you so much!
-You bet Super duper thank you, for watching this video. It’s a long video, but it’s so special. I mean I’ve loved rockets forever, Always have, always will, and this is like rockets and manufacturing–the Venn diagram right there that sweet spot, this is what this is for me, it’s wonderful. So thank you for watching this video. If you feel like this type of video earned your subscription, one way you can signal that to me is by subscribing. You can click on the subscribe button and there’s a little notification bell; if you click that, it’ll notify you when I upload, and that’ll encourage me to do more stuff like this. Big thanks to ULA and Tory Bruno, you trusted me with your rocket factory, so thank you very much! Also, you can support on Patreon, if you’re into that sort of thing. I’ve got something coming up in the near term, that the Patrons have made happen, and it’s fantastic. audible.com/smarter or text the word “smarter” to 500-500, I recommend “Seveneves” or Mary Robinette’s book “The Calculating Stars”, Yeah, that’s about it! I’m just really happy, and very grateful, and thank you for being here with me. That’s it. I’m Destin, you’re getting Smarter Every Day. Have a good one, bye.

Only registered users can comment.

  1. Thanks for watching this video. I'm glad you're here. If you feel like this earns your subscription please click here: http://bit.ly/Subscribe2SED

    How this happened: I messaged Tory "If you ever find yourself with an open lunch I'll buy. No cameras, just rocket geek chat."
    A few months later he changed a flight one day so we could grab lunch, but he also carved out a couple of hours before lunch to give me a personal tour.
    He's as cool off camera as he is on camera. He allowed me to ask any technical question I had, and I never even got close to the limits of his understanding of rockets. His technical prowess is something I aspire to. We made a video on the second channel where I interview him about more specific things about rockets, as well as how he feels about competitors.
    2nd Channel Interview with Tory about rocket engines, competitors, and business philosophy: https://youtu.be/DQaPOIQLEUo

  2. this rocket is physically the largest rocket in the world…. to bad there is another rocket that can lift more payload.
    Edit it is a sweet video though. definitely watch to the end

  3. Can you message me I have made cables for them when I lived in Colorado I even have a connector with their name on it I can send you pictures

  4. I am always amazed by the top-notch, pure high quality content that you bring to us, Destin. being a space engineering student, it is an absolute delight to watch your videos. I think this is the closest we can go with the ITAR in place. Sincere thanks to you man.

  5. I have a pull cord from ULA on my keychain and whenever someone asks what it is and I tell them it’s a company that builds rockets they always look at me like I’m dumb. As if NASA is the only company that does or something since they’ve never heard of them. Now I can show them this video.

  6. Tory reminds me of one of the old school pilots from the 40s and 50s who became the first astronauts, he reminded me of someone like buzz Aldrin Neil Armstrong or Chuck Yeager.

  7. i’m very interested as to why they used the cross pattern grain structure also interested if the cross pattern grain structure seen from the side angle of the raw stock coincides with the triangle ridges on the finished product

  8. Wow what an awesome CEO, You can tell he really loves his job. What I like most of all is how he continues to bring up the "Human Factor". He's really proud of his guys and gals and is adamant about the programs surrounding ULA. What a great guy. What an amazing opportunity, love that you shared this with us!

  9. If I remember correctly, the Delta system evolved from Titan (an additional ICBM following the first, Atlas).

    The thin wall tanks were innovative on Atlas, and were always pressurized to maintain physical strength and form.

    Very cool video, and many thanks to the company and their team for letting us have a look!

  10. 5:14 Not allowed to film her I guess.

    Oh and I am sure Kim needs to speak to Tory Bruno.
    And wow i never thought RUAG was in on Vulcan.

  11. Incredibly well done video. I was stationed at Redstone Arsenal in Huntsville. That is an amazing area. One of my favorite places in the world.

  12. thoroughly enjoyed that thank you ) Its almost criminal that its just burnt up or smashed into the ocean at a couple of hundred miles an hour to corrode /erode away in a few months ! What a shame they can't land it back somewhere to either be reused or salvaged

  13. I can't subscribe because you haven't said hi to me personally. But I will say that was a really awesome video to watch

  14. This is amazing! I want to see more videos like this and at this length!!

    Please go back and do another long video with them!!!

    Tory Bruno is cool!!

  15. This is so incredible and I have so many questions, but my number one is how do they re-anodize the aluminum after the friction stir weld. I would assume that anodizing everything and then re-exposing everything to air after the weld would negate the whole previous process.

  16. The amount of engineering put into this is so crazy, I cannot imagine the amount of intellect and creativity put into all the steps like the welding. It blows my mind, can’t wait for the future.

  17. Absolutely MAGNIFICENT! How many CEOs in ANY industry could walk any of their company’s manufacturing/assembly facilities and display such comprehensive grasp and sequential knowledge. Mr. Bruno is one exceptional human being! God Bless America.

  18. i really enjoyed this video. thank you. amazing to see how many different and highly engineered tools and gripping rigs are used in the manufacturing process.

  19. I know you're being respectful. There needs to be some commentary on cost, SpaceX competition, and the actual viability of the reusable technology of the Vulcan rocket. It was a fascinating video, but definitely incomplete

  20. Started watching this video not knowing it was 54 minutes and I got to the end and was shocked cause I was so sucked into the video.

  21. This has got to be the best video Smarter Every Day has ever done! Great work sir, Destin Sandlin. Thank you for this.

  22. So what happens to the stuff that doesn’t go to space and returns back to earth? Where does that go? How do they track that stuff?

  23. Thank you Destin and Tory! This is an incredible video and thank you for sharing your access with all of us!

  24. Weird, my youtube feed completely ignores all new smarter every day videos, thank you for the twitter notification though ☺️

  25. 26:47 – I was waiting for Destin to yell "SNATCH BLOCK!" LOL Dude, your channel is my FINAL Destin Nation!!! Love your stuff, brother!! Thank you!!!

  26. I'm only 4min into the video and I am more excited then waiting for my birthday cake at age 5 and I am 40. The CEO is truly an awesome guy! Highly motivational and humble in his appearance and deliverance! I admire the CEO!

  27. This is the best hour I have spent in a while. Thanks to Mr. Bruno & you for this informative journey.

  28. I just watched a video about Einstein, where they quoted him as saying he wanted to understand God's mind mathematically. While watching you I've always thought "This guy's a Christian, probably a Southern Baptist" :). I have a funny story about Billy Graham along those lines.

  29. This is the single most interesting, informative, and in depth video on YouTube. This wins the internet!

  30. I have never understood the appeal or reason for taking rockets to Mars or any other planet. It seems like a massive waste of money when it could be used for so many other projects that benefit everyone.

  31. Thanks for taking time to have actual captions for the Deaf. Makes it so much easier to understand, and technical terms get spelled correctly.

  32. THANK YOU, THANK YOU for making this video! I have always loved space and the exploration of space. I hardly ever comment on anything but this was so amazing and awesome to watch and learn! Your channel ROCKS. The personal tour BY THE CEO is so cool to begin with, BUT how personal he is with his whole staff, how knowledgeable he is on basically everything that goes on there, and his own genuine excitement about what goes on was all so impressive! Please keep making great videos and all the best luck in future endeavors! So jealous too that you got to go inside.

  33. this is so wholesome, educational, and unbelievably interesting to watch from start to finish.

    thank you very much, and
    keep up the good work Destin!

  34. Absolutely best video yet Destin. Actually beats many documentaries that you see on Television. Outstanding

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *